🔍 Case Overview:
In one more commercial case (Judgment No. 296/2020/KDTM-PT issued on May 13, 2020, by the Ho Chi Minh City People’s Court), a dispute arose between Company A (Investor) and Company C (General Contractor) regarding a construction contract for the A&B Saigon Tower project.
Company A terminated the contract, citing delays and substandard construction quality, and demanded:
✅ Refund of overpaid advances: 4.3 billion VND
✅ Penalties for delay: 10.8 billion VND
✅ Compensation for damage: 5.1 billion VND
💰 Total liability: 20.58 billion VND (~$860,000)
The Defendant (Company C) appealed, arguing:
– The contract was mutually terminated, as Company A had no construction permit at the time.
– The delays were not significant, and they had rectified all alleged quality issues.
– The penalties imposed were unjustified.
⚖ Legal Analysis & Court Ruling
The court upheld the original judgment, emphasizing key legal points:
📌 Breach of contract: The contractor failed to meet deadlines, exceeding the contractual limit of 42 days for delays.
📌 Quality defects: Expert reports confirmed non-compliance with design standards, requiring costly remedial work.
📌 Penalty enforcement: The agreed penalty clause (8% of the unfulfilled contract value) was enforceable under Vietnamese law.
📌 Evidence burden: The contractor failed to provide counter-evidence proving compliance or mitigating factors.
📢 Key Takeaways for Businesses
💡 1. Contract Clauses Matter – Ensure your contract includes clear deadlines, penalties, and termination conditions to avoid disputes.
💡 2. Documentation is Key – Always maintain detailed records of project progress, approvals, and issue resolutions to defend against claims.
💡 3. Legal Compliance First – Proceeding without a construction permit weakens the investor’s position and may lead to mutual liability risks.
💡 4. Effective Dispute Resolution – Early mediation or arbitration can prevent costly litigation and preserve business relationships.
📢 Final Thought
This case serves as a critical lesson for both investors and contractors in the construction industry. Contractual non-compliance and project mismanagement can lead to severe financial consequences.
What are your thoughts on contract enforcement in construction projects?
Link PDF: https://drive.google.com/file/d/14qxk7SYKdqm8Ms_Qb56b726ZMfqNWeyF/view?usp=sharing

Should you need any legal support, don’t hesitate to reach out to our Lawyers & Associates. We are pleased to assist your legal need.
THE LAM LAW LLC
🏢Indochina Park Tower, # 4 Nguyen Dinh Chieu Str, Dakao Ward, Dist 1, Ho Chi Minh City.
📞Tel: +84 (0)28 710 58 222 – 6288 3798 – Hotline: +84 (0) 97 309 77 77
✉ Email: info@thelamlawllc.com
Related Posts
Happy Reunification Day & International Labor Day
On the occasion of Vietnam’s Reunification Day and International Labor Day, THELAM LAW extends our
Apr
THE LAM LAW proudly supports Training in Commercial negotiation and Mediation Skills
🎉 Repost: Summary of VICMC (Vietnam International Commercial Mediation Center) ’s Commercial Negotiation & Mediation
Apr
Announcement of holiday schedule 30/4 – 01/5/2025
THE LAM LAW LLC would like to inform all valued customers and partners about the
Apr
When does a contractual penalty become a legal trap for the claimant?
⚖️ SUPREME COURT OVERTURNS CONSTRUCTION DISPUTE RULING – A CASE STUDY IN PENALTY & DEBT
Apr
Professional exchange – Exploring cross-border collaboration
This afternoon at THE LAM LAW LLC – Your legal need, Our Mission office, Founder
Apr
Office Closure for Hung Kings’ Festival 2025
Dear Valued Customers and Partners, On the occasion of the Hung Kings’ Commemorations, we
Apr