📌 Let’s have a look on the Decision No. 09/2019/QĐ-PQTT, the Hanoi People’s Court declined to annul a VIAC arbitral award worth over 69 billion VND in the case Posco E&C Vietnam vs. KID JSC, despite objections that parties bypassed FIDIC’s Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) and mediation clauses.
Case Highlights:
🔸 The Dispute:
A dispute arose from a FIDIC-based construction contract. The Respondent (KID) argued the arbitration was invalid because the Claimant (Posco E&C) did not initiate DAB or mediation prior to arbitration under FIDIC Clause 20.
🔸 The Contractual Twist:
The parties expressly deleted FIDIC Clauses 20.2 and 20.3 (DAB appointment and decision procedures). As a result, Clause 20.5 on amicable settlement (mediation), which is conditional upon Clause 20.4, was rendered inapplicable.
🔸 Court’s Ruling:
The Court reasoned that when pre-arbitration steps are waived by both parties, it does not constitute a violation of arbitration agreement or Vietnamese procedural public policy. There were no grounds under Article 68 of the LCA 2010 to annul the award.
Legal Analysis:
🔸 Practical Waiver of Multi-tier Dispute Resolution:
Vietnamese courts adopt a contractual autonomy approach. If parties voluntarily omit pre-arbitral steps, arbitration can commence directly — so long as the arbitration clause remains valid.
🔸 Substantive vs. Procedural Review:
The Court reaffirmed its limited review role: it does not reassess the merits or facts, nor interfere with the Tribunal’s evaluation of liability, damages, or breach — preserving the finality of arbitration.
🔸 Pro-arbitration Judicial Policy:
This decision adds to the growing judicial precedent where Vietnamese courts respect the spirit and structure of arbitration, aligning with international best practices.
Key Takeaways for Practitioners:
🔐 Carefully draft dispute resolution clauses in FIDIC-based or complex contracts. Modifications to DAB procedures must be mirrored by corresponding clarity on arbitration triggers.
⚖️ Judicial support of arbitration in Vietnam is real. Article 68 LCA sets a high threshold for annulment — procedural violations must be serious and substantial.
🛡️ Mediation clauses must be enforceable. If contractual clauses are interlinked (e.g., mediation after DAB), removal of one can nullify others.
📎 Pls find full decision as per attachment (Vietnamese):
📝 At THE LAM LAW LLC – Your legal need, Our Mission, we continuously monitor key arbitration developments to equip our clients with the strategic clarity they need.
📩 Need help with contract review, arbitration strategy, or dispute readiness? Let’s talk.
Link PDF: 09.2019 QĐ/PQTT
THE LAM LAW LLC
🏢Indochina Park Tower, # 4 Nguyen Dinh Chieu Str, Dakao Ward, Dist 1, Ho Chi Minh City.
📞Tel: +84 (0)28 710 58 222 – 6288 3798 – Hotline: +84 (0) 97 309 77 77
✉ Email: info@thelamlawllc.com

Tiếng Việt
Related Posts
Holiday Notice Vietnamese Culture Day
Dear Valued Clients and Partners, ⚖️ THE LAM would like to respectfully announce our holiday
Nov
Celebrating Vietnamese Teachers’ Day
On the occasion of Vietnamese Teachers’ Day (November 20), THE LAM would like to express
Nov
The 41st International Residency & Overseas Investment Information Exchange Forum 2026
Behind every cross-border investment decision lies a bigger ambition—growing a business, finding a new home,
Nov
THE LAM congratulates the 19 new members of GES 26 HCMC
THE LAM LAW – Your legal need, Our Mission warmly congratulates the 19 new members
Nov
THE LAM joins hands in response to Vietnam Law Day
On the morning of November 8, 2026, THE LAM LAW LLC participated in the Walking
Nov
THE LAM LAW JOINS THE ISCA COMMUNITY
Connecting expertise. Expanding international collaboration. THE LAM LAW is delighted to have been welcomed
Nov